Skip to main content

Table 2 Description of sociodemographic, psychiatric, and criminal background and murder characteristics of NGRI and guilty groups

From: Guilty or not guilty by reason of insanity? a comparative study of murderers referred for psychiatric examination by court order

 

All Sample (N=128)*

Guilty Group (n = 56)

NGRI Group (n = 72)

Statistic

Demographics

 Age at offence

34.9 (12.3)

34.1 (12.3)

35.6 (12.3)

t(126) = 0.48, p = 0.48

 Migrant

   

χ2(1) = 5.85, p = 0.016

  Yes

32.8% (42)

21.4% (12)

41.7% (30)

 

  No

67.2% (86)

78.6% (44)

58.3% (42)

 

 Family status

   

χ2(2) = 8.35, p = 0.015

  Single

54.7% (70)

44.6% (25)

62.5% (45)

 

  Married

25.0% (32)

37.5% (21)

15.3% (11)

 

  Divorced

20.3% (26)

17.9% (10)

22.2% (16)

 

 Area of residence

   

χ2(1) = 21.41, p<0.001

  Center

40.5% (51)

17.9% (10)

58.6% (41)

 

  Periphery

59.5% (75)

82.1% (46)

41.4% (29)

 

 Religion

   

χ2(1) = 22.24, p<0.001

  Jewish

71.1% (86)

49.1% (26)

88.2% (60)

 

  Muslim

28.9% (35)

50.9% (27)

11.8% (8)

 

Psychiatric background

 Hospitalization

   

χ2(1) = 26.48, p<0.001

  Yes

50.8% (65)

25.0% (14)

70.8% (51)

 

  No

49.2% (63)

75.0% (42)

29.2% (21)

 

 Number of hospitalizations

3.6 (7.8)

1.1 (3.6)

5.5 (9.4)

t(95.4) = 3.65, p<0.001

Criminal background

 Criminal background

   

χ2(1) = 1.41, p = 0.24

  Yes

62.0% (75)

67.9% (36)

57.4% (39)

 

  No

38.0% (46)

32.1% (17)

42.6% (29)

 

 Alcohol use

   

χ2(1) = 0.63, p = 0.43

  Yes

44.7% (51)

49.0% (24)

41.5% (27)

 

  No

55.3% (63)

51.0% (25)

58.5% (38)

 

 Drug use

   

χ2(1) = 0.10, p = 0.76

  Yes

54.4% (62)

52.8% (28)

55.7% (34)

 

  No

45.6% (52)

47.2% (25)

44.3% (27)

 

Murder characteristics

 Place of murder

   

χ2(2) = 2.12, p = 0.35

  Home

59.4% (76)

53.6% (30)

63.9% (46)

 

  Street

16.4% (21)

21.4% (12)

12.5% (9)

 

  Other

24.2% (31)

25.0% (14)

23.6% (17)

 

 Accomplice

   

χ2(1) = 12.35, p<0.001

  Yes

9.4% (12)

19.6% (11)

1.4% (1)

 

  No

90.6% (116)

80.4% (45)

98.6% (71)

 

 Victim number

   

χ2(1) = 0.19, p = 0.67

  One

90.6% (115)

89.3% (50)

91.5% (65)

 

  Two or more

9.4% (12)

10.7% (6)

8.5% (6)

 

 Victim acquaintance

   

χ2(1) = 0.41, p = 0.52

  Yes

89.1% (114)

91.1% (51)

87.5% (63)

 

  No

10.9% (14)

8.9% (5)

12.5% (9)

 

 Victim relation

   

χ2(4) = 5.03, p = 0.28

  Parents

19.5% (25)

12.5% (7)

25.0% (18)

 

  Spouse

21.9% (28)

26.8% (15)

18.1% (13)

 

  Family

15.6% (20)

14.3% (8)

16.7% (12)

 

  Acquainted

32.0% (41)

37.5% (21)

27.8% (20)

 

  Stranger

10.9% (14)

8.9% (5)

12.5% (9)

 

 Conflict

   

χ2(1) = 0.14, p = 0.71

  Yes

68.0% (83)

69.8% (37)

66.7% (46)

 

  No

32.0% (39)

30.2% (16)

33.3% (23)

 

 Planning

   

χ2(1) = 0.37, p = 0.54

  Yes

48.8% (60)

51.8% (29)

46.3% (31)

 

  No

51.2% (63)

48.2% (27)

53.7% (36)

 

 Weapon

   

χ2(3) = 3.40, p = 0.094

  Gun

12.5% (16)

16.1% (9)

9.7% (7)

 

  Knife

51.6% (66)

58.9% (33)

45.8% (33)

 

  Beating with hands or object

18.8% (24)

16.1% (9)

20.8% (15)

 

  More than one

17.2% (22)

8.9% (5)

23.6% (17)

 

 Behavior after murder

   

χ2(3) = 36.20, p<0.001

  Stay/help

42.0% (50)

13.2% (7)

65.2% (43)

 

  Leave/suppress evidence

45.4% (54)

62.3% (33)

31.8% (21)

 

  Suicide

4.2% (5)

9.4% (5)

0.0% (0)

 

  Other

8.4% (10)

15.1% (8)

3.0% (2)

 

 Injured victims

   

χ2(1) = 0.03, p = 0.86

  Yes

17.2% (22)

17.9% (10)

16.7% (12)

 

  No

82.8% (106)

82.1% (46)

83.3% (60)

 
  1. * In some cases there were missing values such that the number does not always total 128 participants.